So far I've been alternating carry and they have been great purchases! Even with dry hands I worry about sliding off of the serrations while trying to manipulate the slide. Usually carry in pocket. This can be a bit of a drawback if youre in a self-defense situation, as it takes an extra step to prepare the gun for firing. Dont give him another gun also. . I prefer the Hornady over SIGs proprietary ammo, as SIGs was hit and miss availability prior to the shortage. If I had 100 people test them, 99 would give this answer and the one who didnt would be you, having never even touched the Ruger. towards your level. Terms of Use | The Taurus is only a little bit bigger than those four, feels great in the hand, and will be much easier to conceal and carry than our blocky Springfield XD and XDm, which was our one major requirement for this purchase. I wanted to try a Hellcat to maybe replace my Shield but with the Shield Plus out now I'm thinking I'll stay with that platform. Impressive. Both Hellcats had less then 200 rounds through them, that tells me something. And I didnt see the allegedly evil image until some of you pointed it out. Micro Compacts are defined by their small size and relatively high magazine capacity. Its a good shooting gun, too. Pro Mags Work In These Guns. . In fact, perhaps its too good? Springfield Hellcat vs Sig P365 (with pictures) | Clinger Holsters. It also weighs slightly more than the P938, at 1.1 pounds. Yeah. My LGS made the remark that since the 365 hit the market the 938 was marked down by SIG to counteract its sales going soft. Two whole ounces more? I owned a LC9S for many years, but got rid of it due to the trigger had become too light. Yep. Nice review! In fact, if my P365 broke tomorrow, Id have no reservations about carrying the Hellcat, though. Check it out! The cost of care and feeding of firearms is pretty well irrelevant. Apex Tactical has a great trigger kit for the Hellcat. The Hellcat 9mm At A Glance See on Brownells - $469.99 See on Palmetto State Armory - $499.99 You do a head-to-head comparison not a heads-up comparison., Oh haha, good point. Maybe the shield plus would make a nice substitute for my walther pps, but I love the paddle mag release on a carry gun as it makes accidental magazine ejection nearly impossible. Don't go through all I did, just get the P365X or XL. I find the P365 to be jumpy and I really have to concentrate to shoot accurately. P365 vs Hellcat personal experience. They vary slightly in shape but arent much different. They are quick to align and rapid on target. The Hellcat implements a standoff device at the front of the gun. Could be they got an outlier. If you are going to be carrying a good bit at night, the included night sights of the P938 are a nice feature, but night sights can easily be added to any weapon. This is not an issue with the Hellcat magazines. If you are more comfortable with a larger gun, the Hellcat may be a better option for you. Taurus G2 and G3 arent micro-compacts. At their price point, why not? This is an interesting article on that very thing: https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-29644591. Quick Cash Offer Get Offer We make you an quick cash offer online We find the dealer that offers you the most money Get cash for your gun or do a trade in Side-by-Side Comparison Charts I agree we are in a golden age. All of the P938s feature aluminum alloy frames and stainless steel slides, so they are extremely durable. Ultimately, I came close. They were never engaging in good faith. Havent held the Ruger but it seems like a best buy for the dough. While all four pistols do offer a manual thumb safety as an option, the MAX-9 was the only gun in our test that was so equipped so we cant compare this feature. It is a great choice for anyone looking for a subcompact 9mm pistol for concealed carry. Copyright 2022 | Gun Digest | All Rights Reserved. It ships with both an 11-round flush fit magazine and a 13-round magazine. The Walther is way ahead. I have three of the Nanos and one now has 14,000 rds down range. Why would the update the article and make it about that model? If you see that terrible WWII national socialist symbol in innocent things like this picture then youre the one with the problem and youre the one glamorizing those horrible national socialist fascists and continuing to give them power, not me or this community. This is a pet peeve of mine, but Im always annoyed by TTAG listing the MSRPs of the firearms, but not the mags. though a terrible value proposition next to any of these. But which one is the best for you? Back to the Shield, IMO the slide serrations are just fine, you are nitpicking. So keep reading as we stack these two models up against each other, look at their specs and features, and ultimately help you decide which one is right for you. I really think you need to update the article to include this latest model as it's a real winner. I have a Sig 365SAS and it has become the most often carried pistol in my collection. You can get the Hellcat with a thumb safety if you would like. It probably will come down to what type of trigger you prefer in a carry gun (pocket capable). Every single one of these pistols is reliable, accurate, and easy to conceal. You can grip tight, and the gun wont move. How do these two handguns stack up against eachother? It hasnt let me down yet. Weighing in at just over a pound, the P938 is easy to carry and conceal. And to all the commentators crying about their Taurus (get some tissue paper) its in a different league (with SCCY, Bersa and even HiPoint. Ive always considered my personal EDC since 2018, my P365 seen in these photos, to be a highly controllable gun and dang do I shoot the thing quickly and accurately, but without a doubt it has the most felt recoil and muzzle flip of the guns in this quadfecta. He lives outside of Austin, TX. All the others have simple, captive (you dont remove them from the frame) takedown levers that you rotate 90 to release the slide. Available in FDE or Black. Its an extremely easy micro-compact to shoot well. I LOVE the Shield though. Been seriouly considering buying the 365 simply because I do not have it. After shooting all four guns, I wont be trading in my P365. Im Jewish and I approve the perfectly benign lead photo. The PF9 is a lower capacity single stack pistol. Shoehorning 10+ rounds into a skinny micro-compact was and certainly still is a fantastic recipe for sales success, and, as this very article shows, others have jumped into the fray. On the plus side, this small amount of additional size packs a large amount of prowess on the range. Its about like using a 19 mag in a 26. I would put on them or above the level the Glock, Glock has been resting on their laurels for a couple of decades. Ive never thought of the M&Ps serrations as sub-par or anything, and theyre without a doubt plenty functional and nothing I would normally complain about, but in this heads-up comparison they simply dont compete on the same level as the P365s and MAX-9s. There are a few things to consider when deciding whether to purchase a Hellcat or a SIG P365. And stay in touch with newsletters of our best articles on techniques, guns, & gear. Overall its controls, including its takedown method, are the most difficult to use of the four guns. The OG P365 is good, but the newer models are better. My P365 replaced the Nano that I had carried for the prior 6 years. The P365s lower profile sights are smaller and allow me to see more of the target. I really like the Smith and if I were buying a new sub carry that would probably be it. Check out this excellent review of the P365 and the Hellcat! Next is the Ruger MAX-9, which is only very slightly less "flippy" than the P365, then there's a jump to the Springfield Hellcat, which is noticeably softer, and then another solid leap to the Smith & Wesson M&P9 Shield Plus, which shoots like a well-tuned compact, not a sub-compact or micro-compact. The only downside is that it doesnt have night sights like the Hellcat. I believe its a more welcoming community than almost any other group that rallies behind any other cause, and this belief is based on my experience being with this group at events and conferences and conventions and on hunting trips and training sessions and whatever else for nearly a decade. I had to get used to what to do with my pinky finger with the std 10 round magazine but that just took a little practice. A series of similar articles about different guns, chosen for whatever reason, would be useful. As an example of an on-paper stat that may be misleading in real life, while the Hellcat is shorter in max height than the P365, its backstrap is longer so its heel sticks out a little farther than the P365s. Anyway, pushing out that takedown pin is no big deal. 1 more deal from grabagun.com 469.99 View Deal Springfield Armory Hellcat Micro-Compact Osp Or 1 more deal from guns.com 499.99 View Deal Well its technically its not even that, its just close enough that people not in the know could mistake it. Yall really should swap out that photo with something else. What that picture reminds me of is one of those pyrotechnic pinwheel things, before ignition of course. Mag spring pressures are higher in smaller guns and using the same ammo which includes +P means that propels the lighter, shorter slide even faster than a full size duty gun. The Taurus G2 and G3 are noticably larger than these guns. Competition is good, though, and the P365 currently has a butt load in that arena. Of the guns you've mentioned, the only one I have is the Kimber Micro 9. Sights are great and allowed us to shoot rapidly and accurately. In either case, though, Id describe both triggers as very good well above the average for compact (or sub-compact or micro-compact) polymer pistols of its time. COPYRIGHT 2021, THETRUTHABOUTGUNS.COM. I set up a B27E target and first tested the Hellcat. I did shoot a P365 and shot it very well also but I like the trigger better on the Shield Plus. A very unscientific, but hopefully helpful comparison.https://www.patreon.com/gunsandthegospel Good luck and keep us informed of your decision. As for the whole thing, its an opinion piece including your photo. XDE is a little bit heavier and bulkier becasue of the hammer configuration but tolerable. Quick Cash Offer Get Offer We make you an quick cash offer online We find the dealer that offers you the most money No argument on the quality of the steel sights. Im definitely not a fan of the rounded-notch rear with white outline, though obviously this is personal preference. Probably Sig P365. Its about an inch shorter and half an inch narrower. May invest in the XL soon for my wife. I want a clean, small gun that I can conceal, fire accurately, and not have to worry about things going wrong in the heat of the moment. Taurus gets no respect but deserves some. It wasnt as easy to carry as the Taurus 85 that I sold to buy it, and it was painful to shoot compared to every other carry gun Ive ever owned. My Shield is from 2018. Spend more,upgrade and dont you dare say true statements. I have had many over the years. Dont believe the Keltec trash talkers, Ive owned four different Keltaec models and theyre all accurate and reliable. So I agree, the P11 isnt even close to the 4 you picked to review. mag it still conceals in my pocket . the left side of each one) and I wanted them in a format that didnt appear to rank them or whatever. Well I sorta recommended the Sig to my friends wife. Ive owned my SIG P365 since mid 2018, so Im coming up on 3 years. We already have an account registered for email address It weighs only 18.3 ounces with an empty magazine. The Hellcat also has a GripZone frame that is designed to provide a more comfortable and secure grip. OVERALL LENGTH: 6.0 in. Okay, onto our thoughts of how each micro-compact concealed carry handgun stacks up compared to the others: SIGs little P365 shook up the concealed carry market when it was released in early 2018. The Hellcat is out for a couple of reasons, I had a chance to buy two at the beginning of the panic. Not too many play with the 938 safety, and fewer still would delete it SIG sells the 365 proven safe without it and you can add one as you please. Saving a bunch up front make more mags an overall cheaper expense, and behold! It is also a semi-automatic pistol, so if you are looking for a gun to use for self-defense, the Hellcat may be a better option. From a practical standpoint it was probably the best weapons purchase I ever made. Choose accordingly. Its a great gun and it was extremely reliable and accurate and easy to carry. Good review. The Hellcat is also a subcompact 9mm pistol, but it is slightly larger than the P938. The P938 from Sig Sauer is chambered for 9mm Luger ammunition. Most of the issues I have had have been from bad ammo rather than the actual gun. Between the 938 and the Micro 9 I'd go with the 938. The Taurus is even farther off. I find the Max9 to be a vastly superior shooter over the 365 in terms of recoil management, and the optics ready slide is a big plus. P365XL Spectre: Special model of the XL with slide cuts, a different grip texture, X-series trigger, and optics-ready capability. With todays selections you can find a pistol that is virtually custom built. Id put it head-to-head with a GLOCK 19, for instance, and I expect most shooters would outperform on speed and accuracy with the Shield Plus. TTAGs Managing Editor, Dan Zimmerman, and I took all four of the hottest, most in-demand concealed carry guns on the market the four micro-compacts with double-digit capacity, flush-fit magazines and hit the range. It is 6.75 inches long and 4 inches tall. Obviously, I like it. That means you get to swap grip units smaller or larger as you like with SIGs supplies, and as time goes by, with aftermarket grip units just like the 320. Your email address will not be published. The SIG trigger though doesnt compare to my Walther PPQ. And we made the mistake of thinking that they were normal people like us, just a little too sensitive, and that theyd get over it or grow up and we could all go about our business. Bullseye sight took a small adjustment period, but once used to it I find the little pistol very accurate to the 25 yards I would expect from the short barrel. This P365 and a P365XL are the only Sigs I own or have ever owned, actually. Anyway, three years later and the P365 still feels the smallest of these four handguns. Considering that the last few times we've done videos on individual micro compact carry guns we get comments asking for opinions on some of the less well-known options, we decided to speed run 5. He got lucky and got one about a month ago. vs Sig Sauer P938 Nitron SAO Subcompact Pistol Chambered in 9mm Luger Check Price Dimensions Details Capacity Dimensions Customary Metric Want to sell a firearm? It may not display this or other websites correctly. Exactly! What you do notice is more muzzle flip than the other guns. The writer of the article is doing a comparison off of the base models of each pistol. The Sig P938 and the Hellcat are both 9mm pistols that are popular among gun enthusiasts. So, you trade it in. For an MSRP premium of just $30, youd be silly not to buy the optics-ready Hellcat. No, of course not. I simply love how the Shield Plus shoots. Springfield also [literally] one-upped the P365s capacity by squeezing 11 rounds into the Hellcats magazine. One could argue that the tritium-illuminated fiber optic front sight on the MAX-9 is better, but my eye prefers the P365s front dot. I am wondering if the trigger is the same now on the Max 9? Hellcat: $569 (Pistol) + $290 (mags) = $859 They also had the Sig in stock. For me, Im sticking with the original I like the P365 the best. Ive also owned just one s&w polymer pistol, an original m&p 9 pro, with around 25,000 rounds through it. Theyre not the problem. Trigger pull on the MAX-9 feels far lighter than its approximately five-and-a-half-pound break weight. Love the four the hard way review. PS Many of us rated the 365 the bottom of the list. Some people prefer the simplicity of the striker-fired action, while others like the lighter trigger pull of the single-action only trigger. If and when prices return to somewhat normal the S&W and Ruger will be close in price. It's my second most accurate gun. I had one of those, but it always squirmed around in my hand when I fired it. The P938 also has a manual safety, which some shooters prefer. You wont beat the price. Overall this is a very good trigger, and doubly so for anyone who prefers a rolling style break. Its still small, of course, so itll fit basically anyones hand (or at least shouldnt be too large for anyone), but I just find it weird. The P290 with double action only, and the P938 with the single action only and external safety. Ive not had the opportunity to fire the Ruger or S&W yet. I sold my 365, 365XL, and Shield when I changed over to a Wilson Combat X9S as my primary carry gun a year ago. The stereotype of Taurus semi-autos being junk is just that, a stereotype. Great guns. Getting sight focus with either isnt tough to do and getting lead on target quickly isnt tough to do either. It's been my main cc gun when I'm not at work. No. It is one of the newest pistols on the market and has already gained a loyal following. This gun is optics-ready and comes with a flat-faced trigger. I own about 15 now, but you can never have enough. As pointed out in other comments below, if you compare it to the hateful symbol the arms of this pistol arrangement point the wrong direction, it isnt canted 45 degrees, etc etc. Obviously, the Hellcat has caught my eye. Excellent. Select what level shooter you are! As we get older we see these for what they are, a short lived fashion accessory. The first trip to the range was the real eye opener. MODEL: SIG Sauer P938 Emperor Scorpion CALIBER: 9mm ACTION: Short Recoil, Locked Breech TRIGGER: Single Action BARREL LENGTH: 3.0 in. I agree with you, the a wasp micro-dot on the hellcat would help with the slide, so Im waiting to get one. Sigs first competitor came from a company called Springfield Armory by way of Croatia. Thanks! You have entered an incorrect email address! They hold a bunch of rounds, are small, and are both striker-fired, with polymer frames. As mentioned above, the Hellcat shoots pretty darn softly given its lilliputian size and light weight. Haven't had the opportunity to check out a Hellcat. Dry fired the other models and felt they were all a little small for my hand size. We'll only use the information provided according to our privacy policy. The Hellcat has a capacity of 11+1 rounds of 9mm Luger. So of course I go home with one along with a Blackpoint IWB holster with two leather wings that was listed as a Sig accessory at the time. I train with this pistol at 10 - 15 yards and get good groups. Flawless operation and for such a small gun the 365 was very accurate. It also by FAR the best shooter out of the three I have shot. I preferred the long slide on the shorter grip, small to carry but shot better with more barrel. Can use up to the 33 round magazine if you really need capacity. It weighs just under a pound, making it a very lightweight and easy to carry option. anything extra and your Its like the Pepe the frog controversy. Consider your needs and make the decision that is right for you. It has more customization options more holsters, and I have far more training on it than the Hellcat. Thanks to the larger grip circumference and different shape of the Hellcats grip, it feels and shoots like its larger than the P365 even if ones pinky is wrapped under the mag. The Hellcat has a polymer frame and a stainless steel slide, and it comes with tritium night sights. Available in FDE or Black. The 938 is busier and lacks that simplistic 1911 look, much less the grip proportioning giving off the vibe its trying to chamber 5.7 FN. And yes the mags rust easily. Required fields are marked *. Affiliate Disclaimer | The reset travel is fairly short and the reset is nicely tactile and audible. The password should contain at least 8 characters with at least one number or special character. Subscribe to Pew Pew Tactical's sales and deals email. I also shoot it a little faster and more accurately. The Hellcat has a very impressive capacity, with 11+1 and 13+1 magazine options available. This means that it can handle more power and produce more vapor. Perhaps that change in angle also helps, but whatever the secret is the end result is extremely effective slide serrations that you wont slip off of. I usually buy one box of my preferred carry ammo, Hornady Critical Duty 135 gr +P, a month to cycle, on top of handloaded target rounds, but since Sept. 2020, Im just running target ammo. If the judges give the MAX-9s slide serrations a 10, the P365 gets an 8, the Shield Plus a 4, and the Hellcat a DNF. At 25 yards, I have an AR. The sig is a fantastic little gun that shoots well and stays on target well for follow up, and the day night sights are easy to acquire. Theyre one of the worse far-left rags sites when it comes to just taking some random thing theyve seen and inventing whole narratives. you a link to reset your password. In general, I figure the most expensive thing is probably ammo (especially now), then mags, then the difference in price of the gun. Not any worse than using a 33-rd stick in a Glock 26. Front-to-rear length of the grip frame is also significantly longer than any of the other guns here. To summarize that, I sold the P938. Got it on sale for a little under $700 with the red dot included. And I never want to return to the Light Crisp Triggers. All in all I think I would rather have the Walther PPQ sub compact or even the M&P sub compact. With drills like Dot Torture and the iHack, I tend to drop rounds with the Hellcat, but less so with the Sig.
Po Box 21823 Eagan Mn 55121 Provider Phone Number, Fred Meyer Digital Coupons Sign In, Michael Sterk Chicago Wedding, Premier Boat Sales Smithville Tn, Articles H